I have the urge to play devil's advocate....
I'm usually the prolix one in a thread

, but this time I'm going to simplify and keep this message shorter than OrangeSVS's.
I've had discussions with riders, especially cruiser/chopper types, who find my approach to choosing a motorcycle cold-blooded. They have a Romantic concept of what it is to choose a motorcycle. I do not.
When it comes to motorcycles, I'm a function-over-form kind of guy. Does it do the job I want it to do? Is there a good dealer nearby to help me keep it in good working order? Etc. If yes, then maybe I buy and ride it. If no, then I don't. How it looks is subsidiary to how it works.
There are many bikes out there that do roughly what I want a motorcycle to do. I own two of them. I continue to own a third primarily for nostalgia, although even it does certain jobs very well.
There are many bikes out there that do jobs for which I currently have no use, such as race replicas, off-road dirt bikes, full-dress tourers, etc. They do their jobs well; they just do jobs for which I currently have no use, or not enough use to make the purchase.
Then there are bikes that do not do their jobs as motorcycles well. The aesthetic is one of form over function: the intended job is merely to look a certain way, with all else, including functionality, compromised for the appearance.
These bikes hold no interest for me.
Furthermore, in many cases these bikes do certain things particularly poorly. One of them is muffle sound. Many of these bikes are terrible at being socially quiet. They also often handle poorly, ride poorly, produce excessive vibration, and break down.
I honestly don't remember if I've ridden specifically a Big Dog. I've ridden other similar bikes. I just don't like them.