So...
Looking for a more touring orientated bike for the girl friend; something that can fit luggage and has slightly better wind-protection that the SV650.
Local shop, run by a friend, has a 2000 VFR800 for sale. Price looks a bit high, but what the hell -- it's the 5th Gen, it's yellow, can't hurt to go look at it.
Turns out it has a salvage title; it's been down on the right side and is fairly rashed up and they salvage titled it because the cosmetics would cost too much to repair. Now the price looks /way/ high, but the owner is apparently 'very willing to deal'.
22K miles. PPI says mechanically sound and the cosmetics aren't even TOO bad. I'm leery of the whole salvage title thing in general, because reselling it is sure to be a nightmare if you ever want to, but it could be a chance to steal her a 5th gen VFR.

What's a reasonable offer? NADA low retail says $2500, so I'm thinking around the $2K mark.